← The Four Pauls
Paul Alexis Cifaldi I as a small child
Paul I

Paul Alexis Cifaldi I

1916–1962

Father
Alexis (Alessio) 1880–1956
Mother
May 1889–1963
Sister
Ruth 1918–2005
Wife
Gladys
Children
Paul II, Robert, Stephen, and Diane

The first Paul in America. His father, Alessio, was born in Campolattaro, near Benevento, on December 7, 1880, to Vito Cifaldi and Antonia Urso. He studied at Cornell Medical College and became a physician in New York City, with an office on East 116th Street in East Harlem. The middle name Alexis comes from him.

The name wasn’t new, though. Alessio’s grandfather, back in Campolattaro, was a Paolo.

Paul was born in New York on April 2, 1916. He skipped medicine for his mother’s side of the family: May was a Gargiulo, and the Gargiulos were in the produce business. By 1958 he was president of Gargiulo & Amendola Associates, a wholesale fruit and vegetable firm at 282 Washington Street, in Manhattan’s Washington Market. He and his wife, Gladys, raised Paul II, Robert, Stephen and Diane in Westchester County.

He died suddenly of a heart attack in August 1962, at 46, on a business trip to Miami, the city where Paul II was in college.